Battery vs. Hydrogen in Heavy-Duty Transport – Which Drive Type Will Prevail?

The smarter E Podcast Episode 126 | March 2, 2023 | Language: German

Electromobility is also picking up speed in freight transport. This raises the question of the most versatile type of drive. Regardless of developments in the passenger car segment, this niche is often seen as a "safe haven" for hydrogen propulsion (H2). The reasons given for this are the insufficient range of battery trucks, charging times that are too long, and the reduced payload due to the heavy battery. While battery-electric vehicles have prevailed over H2 in private transport, there is still some debate in heavy-duty transport. But which type of drive will prevail in the long term? What role do range, infrastructure and, above all, economy play? We talk about this with Christopher Hecht from the Institute for Power Electronics and Electrical Drives at RWTH Aachen University and Member of the Project Hydrogen Compass.

Timeline:

  • 1.36: Hydrogen in the passenger car sector seems to make less sense. How does it look in heavy-duty transport?
  • 12.43: A look at the infrastructure - how many charging points are needed?
  • 19.47: Comparison of energy sources: What are the respective ecological advantages and challenges of BEVs and hydrogen vehicles?
  • 22.31: Economic efficiency: Which type of drive will prevail in the long term?

The smarter E podcast is all about the current trends and developments in a renewable, decentralized and digital energy industry. Our moderators Tobias Bücklein and Zackes Brustik welcome and interview personalities who shape our industry and drive developments forward. A new episode is published every Thursday.

Click on the logo to listen to the podcast on the platform of your choice.

Christopher's research focuses on applying machine learning and Big Data algorithms to public charging infrastructure for electric vehicles. Key questions are how to best utilize the existing infrastructure, how to best organize future expansion, and how electric vehicles can interact with the power grid in a way that serves the system. Through the platform www.mobility-charts.de as well as through appearances at various conferences, he is a leading voice on the use of charging infrastructure in Germany.

The Institute for Power Electronics and Electrical Drives (ISEA) at RWTH Aachen University was founded in 1965 and has been headed by Prof. Dr. Rik W. De Doncker since 1996. Today, ISEA houses the chairs for Power Electronics and Electric Drives, for Electrochemical Energy Conversion and Storage Systems Technology, and for Battery Aging Processes and Lifetime Prediction. The aim is to optimize existing battery technologies for applications.

The International Exhibition for Charging Infrastructure and E-Mobility
Learn more
Further Content
Press Release
Bidirectional Charging: Unlocking Revenue With Electric Vehicles and Reducing Grid Loads

19. June 2026

There is a clear vision: millions of electric vehicles serving as mobile storage units.

Press Release
Intersolar Europe: Votality Under Control – Solar Industry Enters Next Phase With Hybrid Power Systems

June 12, 2026

Hybrid PV systems combine solar installations and large-scale storage behind a single grid connection point, making the system more flexible.

Press Release
Energy Suppliers recognised with 10th Energy Transition Award by EUPD Research and The smarter E Europe

June 26, 2026

On June 25, 2026, pioneers of the energy transition from the DACH region were awarded the Energy Transition Award 2026 for their comprehensive range of products and services in the field of sustainable energy solutions at The smarter E Europe in Munich, Europe’s largest alliance of exhibitions for the energy industry.

Press Release
Reliable, Cost-Effective and Climate-Neutral – The smarter E Europe 2026 Has Begun and Shows That a 24/7 Renewable Energy Supply Is Possible

June 23, 2026

Today The smarter E Europe 2026 opened its doors to the fully booked halls at Messe München: Until June 25, around 2,800 international exhibitors are presenting their solutions, applications and business models for a 24/7 renewable energy supply.

Press Release
The Smarter E Europe Sends a Strong Message: The Energy Future is Renewable

June 17, 2026

Europe is once again facing an energy crisis, another reminder of just how vulnerable our fossil fuel-based energy system is.

You are using an outdated browser

The website cannot be viewed in this browser. Please open the website in an up-to-date browser such as Edge, Chrome, Firefox, or Safari.